Peer Review Process

 

MAQASID: Journal of Islamic Law and Society applies a Double Anonymous Peer Review process. The identities of the author(s) and the reviewers are concealed from each other throughout the review.

The journal manages its editorial workflow through Open Journal Systems (OJS), which supports the Double Anonymous Peer Review process. Once a manuscript is submitted through OJS, it is recorded in the system and checked by the Journal Manager for completeness and compliance with the author guidelines. The corresponding author then receives an acknowledgement confirming that the manuscript has been received and is under consideration for publication in MAQASID: Journal of Islamic Law and Society.

Every submitted manuscript is first evaluated by the Managing Editor, either alone or in consultation with members of the Editorial Board. This initial screening assesses whether the manuscript fits the journal’s aims and scope and meets its standards of quality and relevance. Manuscripts that do not meet these standards are desk-rejected, and the authors are informed of the reasons.

Manuscripts that pass the initial screening are checked for similarity using Turnitin. The maximum similarity index (SI) accepted by the journal is 25%. Manuscripts with an SI above 25% are returned to the authors for revision until the index is 25% or lower.

Manuscripts that meet the similarity requirement, whether at first submission or after revision, are assigned to at least two reviewers. Reviewers are given 21 days to submit a detailed report and recommend one of the following decisions: accept, minor revision, major revision, or reject. If the reviewers’ recommendations conflict, the Managing Editor examines the reports and the manuscript before communicating the final decision to the corresponding author.

When revisions are required, authors are given 8–12 weeks for minor revisions and 12–16 weeks for major revisions. For minor revisions, the Managing Editor reviews the revised manuscript and the authors’ response to the reviewers, then makes the final decision. For major revisions, the revised manuscript is sent back to the reviewers for further evaluation before an editorial decision is made.

In all cases, the final decision to accept or reject a manuscript rests solely with the Managing Editor. This decision takes into account the reviewers’ recommendations and the journal’s aims and scope.