Peer Review Process

All manuscripts submitted to the Journal of Communication and Education Studies (JCES) undergo double-blind peer review: the identities of authors and reviewers are concealed from each other throughout the process. The whole process takes place in the journal's online system, where all review reports and correspondence are recorded.

Stages

  1. Initial screening (within 7 days). The editor checks scope, manuscript type, compliance with the Author Guidelines and template, anonymisation, and similarity (maximum 25%). Manuscripts that do not meet these requirements are returned or rejected without external review.
  2. Assignment of reviewers. The handling editor invites at least two, and normally three, independent reviewers with expertise in the manuscript's subject, from institutions different from the authors' and, where possible, from different countries.
  3. Review (4 weeks). Reviewers assess the manuscript using the journal's review form and recommend: accept, minor revision, major revision, or reject.
  4. Editorial decision. The handling editor weighs all reports and recommends a decision; the Editor-in-Chief makes the final decision. When reviewers disagree, an additional reviewer may be invited.
  5. Revision (2 weeks for minor, 4 weeks for major revision). Authors revise the manuscript and submit a response letter explaining each change. Revised manuscripts may be returned to the same reviewers.
  6. Acceptance and production. Accepted manuscripts are copyedited, laid out, proofread by the authors, and published online first with a DOI.

The average time from submission to first decision is 6–8 weeks.

Review criteria

Reviewers evaluate the substance of the manuscript, not only its language or layout:

  • Relevance to the focus and scope of the journal.
  • Originality, novelty, and clarity of the research gap and objective.
  • Appropriateness and rigour of the method.
  • Depth of analysis and interpretation, and critical comparison with recent studies.
  • Whether the conclusion answers the research objective and is supported by the data.
  • Quality, recency, and primacy of the references.
  • Ethical compliance, including ethical approval where required.

Reviewer qualifications

Reviewers hold a doctoral degree or equivalent research experience and have published in reputable journals in a relevant field within the last three years. Reviewers do not serve on the editorial team of the journal.

Integrity of the process

  • The journal offers no fast-track review and no guaranteed acceptance.
  • A Letter of Acceptance (LoA) is issued only after the Editor-in-Chief has made the final decision to accept a manuscript.
  • Reviewers do not use AI tools or upload manuscripts to AI applications (see the AI Policy).
  • Reviewers and editors declare any conflicts of interest (see the Conflict of Interest Policy).
  • Editors and reviewers never ask authors to cite the journal or their own publications.
  • The process follows the COPE Ethical Guidelines for Peer Reviewers.

Appeals

Authors who believe a decision was based on a factual error or misunderstanding may send an appeal to the Editor-in-Chief within 30 days, with a point-by-point justification. The appeal is assessed by an editor who was not involved in the original decision, if necessary with an additional reviewer. The outcome of the appeal is final.