Research Misconduct Policy

The Journal of Communication and Education Studies (JCES) takes all allegations of research misconduct seriously and handles them according to COPE flowcharts. Research misconduct includes:

  1. Fabrication: making up data or results.
  2. Falsification: manipulating research materials, procedures, data, or images so that the research is not accurately represented.
  3. Plagiarism: using another person's ideas, text, or results without appropriate credit.
  4. Invalid authorship: guest, gift, or ghost authorship, fictitious identities, or the use of names or affiliations without consent.
  5. Undisclosed conflict of interest.
  6. Multiple or duplicate submission: submitting the same manuscript to more than one journal at the same time, or republishing substantially the same work.
  7. Other violations: citation manipulation, peer review manipulation, involvement of paper mills, and breaches of research ethics.

Ethical clearance

Research involving human participants, including surveys, interviews, observations, and classroom studies with minors, must have ethical approval and informed consent. The article states the number and year of the ethical clearance document.

Reporting an allegation

Anyone may report suspected misconduct by email to the editorial office, giving the article title, a description of the concern, and supporting evidence. Reports are treated confidentially, and the identity of the person reporting is protected.

Handling procedure

  1. The Editor-in-Chief assesses whether the allegation is supported by evidence.
  2. The authors are contacted and given an opportunity to respond, normally within 14 days.
  3. Where necessary, the journal consults independent experts and may ask the authors' institution to investigate.
  4. Depending on the outcome, the journal dismisses the allegation, rejects the manuscript, publishes a correction or an expression of concern, or retracts the article.
  5. In serious cases, the journal may bar the authors from submitting for up to three years and inform their institution.